Is Aya Nakamura Representative Enough of France for the Olympics?
Is Aya Nakamura Representative Enough of France for the Olympics?
The French pop star of Malian descent faces far-fight backlash over her possible Olympics performance
The Background
Aya Nakamura is a renowned French-Malian singer and one of France's biggest music stars. Recent reports suggested that she may sing in front of 300,000 people during the Paris Olympics opening ceremony, possibly performing a song by iconic French singer Édith Piaf.
These reports sparked anger among far-right groups in France, with Nakamura's name receiving boos at a campaign rally for the Reconquête party led by far-right figure Éric Zemmour. A small extremist group called the Natives hung a banner by the River Seine with a derogatory message directed at Nakamura.
In response, Nakamura took to social media, criticising the “racists” and emphasising that she won't be silenced. The Olympics organising committee expressed its support for Nakamura, condemning the racist attacks. French sports minister Amélie Oudéa-Castéra and parliamentarian Antoine Léaument also voiced their support for Nakamura.
Some individuals on the right took issue with Nakamura's use of the French language, but supporters emphasised the importance of accepting diverse cultures.
Carole Boinet of Les Inrockuptibles magazine stated that Nakamura's performance at the Olympics had become even more essential due to the far-right's reaction. Angelo Gopee, the boss of Live Nation France, condemned the racist attacks, emphasising the need for the Olympics to transcend borders.
The Facts
French identity is multifaceted, including ancestry and cultural aspects. The Constitution offers paths to citizenship through birth, descent, and naturalisation. Fluency in French is a strong indicator, but regional languages like Breton or Occitan also exist.
This is reflected by the fact that censuses on race and ethnic origin were banned by the French government in 1978, emphasizing citizenship over ethnicity.
In addition to citizenship, what could be part of national representativeness? Wide-ranging appeal certainly comes at the top of any list. As it happens, Aya Nakamura is one of France's most popular musicians, with broad appeal across the country.
And there's a precedent that demonstrates that ethnic background is not always front and center in how most French people approach representativeness.
On 30 December 2012, actor Omar Sy of Senegalese descent, was voted the favourite personality in France, based on a poll run by Le Journal du Dimanche, coming ahead of fellow actor Gad Elmaleh of Moroccan descent.
The Verdict
So, let’s take a close look at the claim: Aya Nakamura is not representative enough of France to perform at the Paris Olympics opening ceremony. Now, how true is that?
Well, there's no objective answer to how well someone represents a nation. Representativeness is subjective and depends on perspective. Aya Nakamura's popularity and French citizenship make her a valid choice for the Olympics.
However, far-right groups who judge her Frenchness based on ancestry have a narrow view that excludes many French citizens.
The post Is Aya Nakamura Representative Enough of France for the Olympics? first appeared on The African Gazette.